What We Learned

Awardee organizations shared their best practices, challenges and lessons learned with us. Here are some of the most important things we learned.

What We Learned

Awardee organizations shared their best practices, challenges and lessons learned with us. Here are some of the most important things we learned.

shine-shape
Education
Education
shine-shape
Education

Drivers

What local opportunities or needs motivate leaders from different sectors to form collective leadership partnerships?

Key takeaways:

  • Initiatives were most often born out of a desire to: address gaps in the workforce or in student experiences (i.e. disengagement or post-secondary gaps); events that triggered collective action in a community; catalytic funding opportunities; and/or government policy or initiatives.

  • The tendency of organizations to cite multiple factors indicates the importance of developing cross-sector partnerships that can address multifaceted challenges.

  • A balance of designing for student needs/interest and cultivating industry buy-in is vital. While student success often drives initial design, implementation depends on early and sustained industry engagement. Addressing this tension early can strengthen both program relevance and durability.

Possible motivating factors that helped launch Collective Leadership efforts:

  • A gap in the workforce

  • Students graduating without post-secondary plans

  • Student disengagement

  • Low academic attainment

  • Existing strong institutional relationships

  • Catalytic community events

  • Government mandates or opportunities for support

  • A funding opportunity to galvanize collective action

We looked at class of ’09. In 6 months, 26% were not connected to work or education plans, and in 6 years the same population was making approximately $11K a year.

Baltimore's Promise

We looked at class of ’09. In 6 months, 26% were not connected to work or education plans, and in 6 years the same population was making approximately $11K a year.

Baltimore's Promise

awardee spotlight

west alabama works!

Leaders

What competencies do leaders report motivating and sustaining collective leadership partnerships?

Key takeaways:

  • Leaders of initiatives must be able to think in nontraditional ways. Breaking silos (both externally and internally) and stepping outside of the status quo requires innovation and a willingness to break rigid bureaucracies to find solutions to challenges as they arise. The mindset is one of, how do we make this happen, rather than, that can’t happen because there are too many roadblocks. 

  • The emphasis on shared decision-making and student-centered thinking reflects a broader shift from institutional control to collaborative governance—requiring leaders to balance organizational goals with collective priorities.

  • Sustaining the work requires a willingness to pilot, adapt, and learn. Effective leaders foster environments where iteration and responsiveness is the norm.

  • The relational foundation of these efforts—“we just like each other”—reveals the often-overlooked role of interpersonal trust in driving policy and systems change, underscoring the need to cultivate and support the human dynamics behind partnership.

Core competencies leaders possess that motivate and sustain partnerships:

  • Coalition-building mindset

  • Prioritizing collective goals over individual organizational goals

  • Mindset of continuous learning and improvement

  • Ability to build trust quickly and strategically across the partnership

  • Willingness to innovate, break silos, and creatively work within bureaucracies

  • A belief that every student can have post-secondary success

  • Knowing what your expertise is, when to take the lead, and when to take a step back

Trust is built through actions and results. When I need you as much as you need me, these partnerships become relationships. When I know I have this community of problem solvers in industry that will come to the table to work with me rather than me on my own.

West Alabama Works

Trust is built through actions and results. When I need you as much as you need me, these partnerships become relationships. When I know I have this community of problem solvers in industry that will come to the table to work with me rather than me on my own.

West Alabama Works

Practices and Structures

Practices and structures that enable collaboration:


Key takeaways:

  • Shared governance structures—such as steering committees, working groups, and regular meetings—are essential to maintaining coordination, transparency, and momentum across partners.

  • Codifying partnership expectations and commitments through MOUs or similar guiding documents helps ensure sustainability through leadership transitions as well as outlines roles, responsibilities, and can articulate a shared problem partners are working to solve, shared goals, create some common language, and collective markers of success.

  • Policy flexibility at the local and/or state level can support implementation of workforce experiences by enabling cross-institution collaboration, seat time flexibility, and data sharing.

  • Backbone/Intermediary organizations can play a key facilitator role—coordinating initiative management, facilitating communication, and ensuring continuity through staffing, funding, and documentation support.

awardee spotlight

onefuture coachella valley

Models of career pathway partnerships:

Models of career pathway partnerships:

Partnerships can take on many different forms. Here are a few common models of partnership structures.


Entities that could be involved in career pathways partnerships include:

Partnerships can take on many different forms. Here are a few common models of partnership structures.


Entities that could be involved in career pathways partnerships include:

High Schools
High Schools
High Schools
School Districts
School Districts
School Districts
Higher Education Institutions
Higher Education Institutions
Higher Education Institutions
Industries
Industries
Industries
Nonprofit Organizations
Nonprofit Organizations
Nonprofit Organizations
Backbone Support Organizations
Backbone Support Organizations
Backbone Support Organizations
Local/Regional Chambers of Commerce
Local/Regional Chambers of Commerce
Local/Regional Chambers of Commerce
Local Mayors Office for Workforce Development
Local Mayors Office for Workforce Development
Local Mayors Office for Workforce Development
Funders
Funders
Funders

Practices and structures that enable collaboration:

Work with the state or city government to remove barriers or create more flexibility within schools like seat time requirements, age restrictions, scheduling flexibility, and credentialing requirements. These changes allow for more innovative and integrated models.

Future Focused Education

Work with the state or city government to remove barriers or create more flexibility within schools like seat time requirements, age restrictions, scheduling flexibility, and credentialing requirements. These changes allow for more innovative and integrated models.

Future Focused Education

Student Experiences and Outcomes

why-choose

Student Experiences
and Outcomes

why-choose

How do collective leadership partnerships aim to create learning experiences that prepare all young people for the 21st century and lead to more equitable outcomes?

Key takeaways:

  • Ensuring alignment on skill-building, expectations, and credentialing across partners leads to a more streamlined student experience and builds credibility with industry.

  • Workforce-ready skills (also called executive functioning/soft skills) like communication, teamwork, and time management are intentionally developed across partner settings.

  • Programs that integrate real-world learning—such as internships, apprenticeships, and portfolio assessments—make learning more engaging and equip students with transferable, career-relevant skills.

  • Tailored and holistic student supports (e.g. childcare, transportation, academic help, social services, success coaching) remove barriers to participation.

Creating and Facilitating High Quality Student Experiences

Curriculum and Goals
Clear objectives: Learning goals are explicitly defined and connected to both classroom curricula and industry standards.


Career alignment: Experiences are tailored to students' career interests and provide exposure to a range of potential career paths.


Skill development: There is a focus on developing academic, technical, and "21st-century" skills such as communication, problem-solving, and teamwork.


Structured learning: Experiences are sequenced appropriately, starting with awareness and progressing to more in-depth preparation like internships.
Workplace Environment
Meaningful tasks: Students are given complex, relevant, and meaningful tasks that allow them to practice and apply their skills.


Trained supervision: Each student has a trained mentor or supervisor who structures the learning experience at the worksite.


Safe and evaluated placement: Opportunities are evaluated for safety and the quality of learning opportunities.


Connection to real-world scenarios: Experiences bridge the gap between theoretical classroom knowledge and real-world application, with a strong emphasis on hands-on learning.
Collaboration and Feedback
Strong partnerships: Educators and employers collaborate closely, with clearly defined roles and coordination between the classroom teacher and the workplace supervisor.


Regular assessment: There is built-in, regular assessment and feedback to help students monitor their progress and skill mastery.


Student involvement: Youth are involved in choosing and structuring their own experience to increase engagement.

Possible Impact Measures

Quantitative Metrics
Completion and pass rates: Track the percentage of participants who finish the program and the percentage who pass post-training assessments.


Job placement and retention rates: Measure the number of participants who find jobs after the program and how long they stay employed.


Wage and salary growth: Assess the change in income for participants post-training.


Return on Investment (ROI): Calculate the financial return of the program by comparing its costs to the financial benefits it generates, such as increased productivity and reduced errors.


Performance metrics: Monitor job-specific KPIs, such as sales quotas, error reduction, or project completion rates.


Time to completion: Track the average time it takes for participants to complete the program.


Cost per hire: Calculate the cost of hiring an employee after they have completed the program.


Absenteeism and turnover: Measure changes in employee absenteeism and turnover rates.
Qualitative Metrics

Skill proficiency: Use pre- and post-program assessments to gauge skill improvement. This can include self-assessments, manager evaluations, and 360-degree feedback.

Job satisfaction: Survey participants and other employees to measure changes in their job satisfaction.

Participant feedback: Collect feedback through surveys, interviews, and check-ins to understand program relevance and effectiveness from the user's perspective.

Behavioral changes: Observe and evaluate how participants' behaviors change in the workplace after training.

Stakeholder perception: Gauge the perception of supervisors, managers, and customers regarding the skills and performance of program participants.

Skill proficiency: Use pre- and post-program assessments to gauge skill improvement. This can include self-assessments, manager evaluations, and 360-degree feedback.

Job satisfaction: Survey participants and other employees to measure changes in their job satisfaction.

Participant feedback: Collect feedback through surveys, interviews, and check-ins to understand program relevance and effectiveness from the user's perspective.

Behavioral changes: Observe and evaluate how participants' behaviors change in the workplace after training.

Stakeholder perception: Gauge the perception of supervisors, managers, and customers regarding the skills and performance of program participants.

Program-level Metrics

Enrollment rates: Track the number of people who enroll in the program to see if enrollment goals are being met.

Program alignment: Evaluate how well the program aligns with the organization's strategic goals and business needs.

Diversity and inclusion: Measure the program's impact on diversity and inclusion goals within the workforce.

Enrollment rates: Track the number of people who enroll in the program to see if enrollment goals are being met.

Program alignment: Evaluate how well the program aligns with the organization's strategic goals and business needs.

Diversity and inclusion: Measure the program's impact on diversity and inclusion goals within the workforce.

awardee spotlight

future focused education

Key takeaways:

  • Ensuring alignment on skill-building, expectations, and credentialing across partners leads to a more streamlined student experience and builds credibility with industry.

  • Workforce-ready skills (also called executive functioning/soft skills) like communication, teamwork, and time management are intentionally developed across partner settings.

  • Programs that integrate real-world learning—such as internships, apprenticeships, and portfolio assessments—make learning more engaging and equip students with transferable, career-relevant skills.

  • Tailored and holistic student supports (e.g. childcare, transportation, academic help, social services, success coaching) remove barriers to participation.

Creating and Facilitating High Quality Student Experiences

Curriculum and Goals
Clear objectives: Learning goals are explicitly defined and connected to both classroom curricula and industry standards.


Career alignment: Experiences are tailored to students' career interests and provide exposure to a range of potential career paths.


Skill development: There is a focus on developing academic, technical, and "21st-century" skills such as communication, problem-solving, and teamwork.


Structured learning: Experiences are sequenced appropriately, starting with awareness and progressing to more in-depth preparation like internships.
Workplace Environment
Meaningful tasks: Students are given complex, relevant, and meaningful tasks that allow them to practice and apply their skills.


Trained supervision: Each student has a trained mentor or supervisor who structures the learning experience at the worksite.


Safe and evaluated placement: Opportunities are evaluated for safety and the quality of learning opportunities.


Connection to real-world scenarios: Experiences bridge the gap between theoretical classroom knowledge and real-world application, with a strong emphasis on hands-on learning.
Collaboration and Feedback
Strong partnerships: Educators and employers collaborate closely, with clearly defined roles and coordination between the classroom teacher and the workplace supervisor.


Regular assessment: There is built-in, regular assessment and feedback to help students monitor their progress and skill mastery.


Student involvement: Youth are involved in choosing and structuring their own experience to increase engagement.

Possible Impact Measures

Quantitative Metrics
Completion and pass rates: Track the percentage of participants who finish the program and the percentage who pass post-training assessments.


Job placement and retention rates: Measure the number of participants who find jobs after the program and how long they stay employed.


Wage and salary growth: Assess the change in income for participants post-training.


Return on Investment (ROI): Calculate the financial return of the program by comparing its costs to the financial benefits it generates, such as increased productivity and reduced errors.


Performance metrics: Monitor job-specific KPIs, such as sales quotas, error reduction, or project completion rates.


Time to completion: Track the average time it takes for participants to complete the program.


Cost per hire: Calculate the cost of hiring an employee after they have completed the program.


Absenteeism and turnover: Measure changes in employee absenteeism and turnover rates.
Qualitative Metrics

Skill proficiency: Use pre- and post-program assessments to gauge skill improvement. This can include self-assessments, manager evaluations, and 360-degree feedback.

Job satisfaction: Survey participants and other employees to measure changes in their job satisfaction.

Participant feedback: Collect feedback through surveys, interviews, and check-ins to understand program relevance and effectiveness from the user's perspective.

Behavioral changes: Observe and evaluate how participants' behaviors change in the workplace after training.

Stakeholder perception: Gauge the perception of supervisors, managers, and customers regarding the skills and performance of program participants.

Program-level Metrics

Enrollment rates: Track the number of people who enroll in the program to see if enrollment goals are being met.

Program alignment: Evaluate how well the program aligns with the organization's strategic goals and business needs.

Diversity and inclusion: Measure the program's impact on diversity and inclusion goals within the workforce.

awardee spotlight

future focused education